PDA

View Full Version : Solaris review


Scabrous Birdseed
16-03-2003, 20:54:43
Unfortunately I forgot to post it from the office, so you're going to have to do with the PDF version I made for badgering people into giving me work experience.

http://www.snapcase.f2s.com/Johan1.pdf

Scabrous Birdseed
16-03-2003, 20:55:21
Oh god, I just noticed that the incompetent fucking film editors misspelled "Soderbergh". Shit.

Scabrous Birdseed
16-03-2003, 20:56:40
Oh bugger and abomination. Could you move this to the Film forum please? I'm truly dreadfully sorry.

Nav
18-03-2003, 00:28:28
Moved!

King_Ghidra@home
19-03-2003, 20:03:19
Johan i haven't seen Solaris so i can't comment on that, but you are an excellent writer, i'll give you that.

Resource Consumer
20-03-2003, 09:48:32
Well, I've seen both and I rather agree with Johan. It is true that the original is a little on the ponderous side but that allows a greater sense of humanity to emerge. The remake, although not as goddamned awful as I feared it might be, has a very cold and austere feel. It feels in some parts like a mad rush to the conclusion so everyone can go home to earth.

This is particularly true of the parts shot on earth which, in the original are an important part of the whole film, but in the remake have more the feel of an unwelcome advert for the local Indian restaurant.

Nav
24-03-2003, 22:58:27
I decided to buy the book. However I feel I ought really to learn russian and read the original version...